A moonshiners' siege on Main Street, a ghost story at the Supper Club, the volcano that wasn't, and a bear you can see on Whiteside Mountain every October.

Samuel Kelsey and Clinton Hutchinson founded Highlands in 1875. Legend says they chose the spot by drawing two lines on a map, one from Chicago to Savannah and one from Baltimore to New Orleans, and expected a center of commerce to grow where the lines crossed. Commerce went elsewhere, but the town collected plenty of stories in the years since. You can visit the places behind most of the ones below.

The Siege of Main Street, 1885

Highlands was settled mostly by temperance-minded Northerners, and the town had no saloons. Just over the Georgia line, Moccasin Township produced more illegal whiskey than any community in the corner where North Carolina, South Carolina and Georgia meet.

In March 1885, a federal revenue agent arrested two young bootleggers from Moccasin. Highlands had no jail, so he held them at the town's first hotel, then called the Highlands House. Eighteen men from Moccasin, led by four Billingsley brothers, marched on Highlands to free them. According to the old accounts, they brought a written declaration of war.

The two sides traded gunfire across Main Street for three days, between the Highlands House and the Central House, the boarding house that is now Old Edwards Inn. A Highlander named Tom Ford shot from a rooftop and hit a Moccasin man, Tom Ramey, who was hiding behind the Central House. Accounts differ on whether Ramey survived. The Charlotte Observer and The New York Times both reported the fight.

The Moccasin men retreated, then blockaded the road south and threatened to shoot anyone who traveled it. About a month later, Cliff Lovin, a Confederate veteran, took that road anyway and met all four Billingsley brothers, armed. Lovin prayed three times. People in Highlands still quote the third prayer.

“O Lord, if you're not going to help me, at least don't help the Billingsley boys either.”

The brothers passed him without a word and went into the woods, and the fighting stopped for good. Lovin later said he didn't know whether the threat or the prayer had saved him.

See it today: A Legends & Lore marker stands in the median at Main and 4th Streets, across from Old Edwards Inn. It reads: “Moonshiners from Georgia laid siege to Highlands near here in 1885 to free arrested men. War ended peacefully with a threat and a prayer.”

Historic photo of the Highlands House, the hotel where the Moccasin prisoners were held in 1885
The Highlands House, where the revenue agent held his two prisoners.

A Shadow in the Log Cabin

Carpenter Joe Webb built a log cabin in Highlands in 1924, using local materials and hand tools. It housed the Log Cabin Restaurant for decades. Stephanie Burt Williams included the cabin in Haunted Hills, her 2007 collection of ghost stories from Highlands and Cashiers, in a chapter called “Dark Shadow Figure.”

Trailborn restored the cabin, and it reopened in 2025 as Highlands Supper Club. You can order NC pecan trout or Webb's buttermilk fried chicken there now, and ask your server whether anyone has seen the figure lately.

The 1924 Joe Webb log cabin, now Highlands Supper Club
Highlands Supper Club. Photo: Christian Harder, courtesy of Trailborn

The Volcano That Wasn't

Satulah Mountain rises to 4,543 feet on the south side of town. In the late 1800s, people in Highlands reported smoke coming out of cracks in its rock, and some believed the mountain was a volcano. One resident, Mrs. Ed Picklesimer, said she had seen smoke and light there. James Mooney, the government ethnologist who recorded Cherokee stories in these mountains, also noted reports of volcanic activity in the Carolina hills.

Naturalist George Ellison later explained the smoke. On some evenings, mist rises out of the Clear Creek Valley, and an east wind carries it up and over Satulah's bare summit. From town, it looks like smoke.

In 1909, Highlanders raised $500 to buy the summit before a developer could put a hotel on it, and they built a stone shelter there for watching sunsets. You can still find its foundation at the top. The Highlands-Cashiers Land Trust protects the summit today.

Historic black and white photograph of Satulah Mountain
Satulah Mountain. Photo: George Masa

Spearfinger of Whiteside Mountain

Whiteside Mountain has the highest cliffs in eastern North America, and it figures in one of the best-known Cherokee stories. Spearfinger, or U'tlun'ta, was a monster with skin of stone and a long stone forefinger. She could change her shape and usually appeared as an old woman, and she killed people to eat their livers. In the Cherokee story, she began building a bridge of rock through the air from the Hiwassee River to Whiteside. Lightning struck it, and pieces of it still lie along the ridge.

Warriors finally killed her after a chickadee showed them where her heart was: inside her right hand, which she always kept closed. Mooney wrote the story down in the late 1800s, and Cherokee storytellers still tell it.

The Shadow of the Bear

In the second half of October, near sunset, a shadow falls across the lower slopes of Whiteside in the shape of a walking bear. People call it the Shadow of the Bear, and it lasts about half an hour. The Cherokee are said to have regarded the bear as a guardian.

How to see it: Take US 64 east from Main Street about five miles to Rhodes Big View Overlook. Get there by 5:30 p.m. on a clear evening between mid October and the end of the month, and look toward Whiteside from the guardrail.

The Shadow of the Bear on the slopes of Whiteside Mountain at sunset
The Shadow of the Bear on Whiteside Mountain.

Salamanders at Night

The southern Appalachians are known as the salamander capital of the world, and North Carolina has more than 60 species, more than any other state. Most salamanders on the plateau have no lungs. They breathe through their skin, which has to stay wet, so they spend the day under logs and rocks and come out on damp nights. After an October rain, take a flashlight along a trail edge and look low.

Halloween Week on the Plateau

The Enchanted Forest: Tuesday, October 27, 5 to 6:30 pm, at the Highlands Biological Station. Kids trick-or-treat along the forest trails and learn about the animals that live there. Free. Costumes encouraged.

Creepy Critter Crawl: Friday, October 30, 9 to 10 am, at the Highlands Biological Station. A free guided walk to look for the plateau's more unusual creatures.

Halloween on Main: Saturday, October 31, 6pm. Main Street closes to traffic for trick-or-treating, and downtown merchants hand out candy.

The Shadow of the Bear only appears for a couple of weeks each fall. Plan your late October weekend to see it.